Tikka Masala Sauce Instant Pot Stove Spice Cravings

Authentic Tikka Masala Sauce Recipe

This recipe has been long due. Many readers who enjoy Chicken Tikka Masala, and Paneer Tikka Masala recipe from the blog, requested for a Tikka Masala Master Sauce recipe, so they can customize it with their choice of protein.

It’s a super flexible masala sauce recipe where you can build a meal around the sauce, not the other way around! A whole jar of masala sauce comes together in a flash - minimal cooking required! I use this recipe whenever I am entertaining and have a mix of dietary preferences. I make this sauce in bulk, then divide and tweak it to the specific recipe. It’s a great make-ahead sauce and it freezes well too.
So here it is, an authentic Tikka Masala Sauce recipe that can be made in under 30 minutes in the Instant Pot or on the Stove!

What Is Tikka Masala Sauce?

Tikka masala sauce is actually more British than Indian - some even consider it to be the national dish of England! It is said to have been created by a British Pakistani chef, Ali Ahmed Aslam, in Glasgow, Scotland, who improvised a sauce made from yogurt, cream and spices. Well-known British chefs such as Jamie Oliver have brought it into the mainstream. In true definition: Tikka = an Indian dish of small pieces of meat or vegetables marinated in seasoned yogurt and grilled. Masala = any mix of spices ground into a paste or powder for use in Indian cooking. Sauce = the ‘gravy’ that ties everything together.

What Does Tikka Masala Taste Like?

Tikka masala is a tomato and cream (either in the form of heavy cream, yogurt or cashews) based sauce with lots of traditional Indian spices, including ginger, turmeric and red chili powder (to give it that quintessential orange-hue), garam masala, coriander and cumin. It is slightly sweet and earthy in flavor.

Is Masala Sauce Spicy?

The spice factor really depends on the amount of ground red chili in the recipe. I like to use Kashmiri red chili powder, which is a mildly hot red chili native to India. I say mildly hot since it is more of a warm chili flavor rather than hot spicy. If you can’t find Kashmiri chile powder, you can substitute it with 1 teaspoon paprika + ¼ teaspoon cayenne. For a milder tikka masala sauce, simply use an equal amount of paprika and omit the cayenne.

Ingredients

Tikka masala sauce is made-up of easy-to-find ingredients at your local supermarket or Indian food Store. The Indian spice blend, Garam Masala, is widely available in the ethnic food aisles these days, and is also available online. Here’s what you need:

Unsalted Butter (or Ghee): Regular unsalted butter or ghee (clarified butter) can be used interchangeably here. Trader Joe’s sells Ghee that I personally love!Onion + Garlic + Ginger: The onion, garlic and ginger provide a flavorful aromatic base. The sauce will end up being blended until smooth, so there is no need to worry about cutting and chopping to the right size.Diced Tomatoes: One 14.5 ounce can of diced tomatoes and all their juices are a quick and easy tomato base. Alternatively, you can use 4-5 Ripe Roma tomatoes. Raw Cashews: Here is the creamy component that makes this tikka masala recipe unique! Rather than dairy cream or yogurt, the lush and creamy texture is created with raw cashews. In other words, we are essentially creating our own cashew cream! Buy raw cashews in bulk and store the remainder in an airtight container in your freezer.Water: The liquid creates the base for the sauce.Spices:SaltTurmeric PowderGaram MasalaCoriander PowderCumin PowderKashmiri Red Chili Powder (or Paprika, for mild curry)Cardamom PowderDried Fenugreek (Kasoori Methi): Known as Kasoori or Kasuri Methi in the Indian subcontinent, both the dried leaves and seeds are used for cooking. In tikka masala, we want the dried leaves, which are also found in most dried curry blends and jarred sauces.Butter: The sweet cream flavor of butter at the very end adds that special finishing touch and gives the curry a gorgeous shine.Agave (or Honey/Sugar): A touch of sweetness at the very end balances the flavor. A little goes a long way here.

How To Make this Sauce From Scratch

Tikka Masala Sauce is super easy to make in under 30 minutes! Follow the steps below for the Instant Pot or Stovetop method.

Instant Pot Tikka Masala

Turn on Saute and adjust to High. Wait for 30-40 seconds and add butter (or ghee) and chopped onions, cook for 3 minutes, till they soften. (Pic 1)Add minced garlic, ginger and sauté for one minute. Stir in tomatoes, spices, cashews and cook for 2 minutes. Add water and scrape up any brown bits that have stuck to the bottom. Turn off Saute. (Pics 2 - 4).Close lid and pressure cook on HIGH for 5 minutes, followed by a natural pressure release (NPR). If in a rush, QR (quick release) after 5 minutes following your cooker instructions. Unlock and open the lid after the pin drops. Use an immersion blender to puree the sauce to a smooth consistency (Pic 5). If using a traditional blender, wait for the sauce to cool down and then blend to a smooth consistency.Add dried fenugreek leaves and butter and simmer on Saute for 2-3 minutes. Add agave (or sugar/honey) to balance the flavors (Pic 6).

Stovetop Recipe

Heat a heavy bottom pot on medium-high heat, add add butter (or ghee) and chopped onions, cook for 3 minutes, till they soften.Add minced garlic, ginger and sauté for one minute. Stir in tomatoes, spices, cashews and cook for 2 minutes. Add water and stir well. When the sauce comes to a boil, reduce heat to medium, cover the pot and simmer for 15-20 minutes. TIP: Stir a few times to prevent the sauce from sticking to the bottom. If it looks dry, add a little water and continue cooking. Use a hand blender to puree the sauce to a smooth consistency.Add dried fenugreek leaves and butter, then simmer uncovered for 2-3 minutes. Add agave (or sugar/honey) to balance the flavors.

To Blend Or Not To Blend?

My family enjoys a smooth and creamy tikka masala sauce (which is how it is prepared in Indian restaurants). Since this is a homemade tikka masala sauce made with cashews, blending it with an immersion blender is necessary to reach that silky smooth consistency. If you don’t have an immersion blender, simply cool the sauce and transfer it to your blender to blend until smooth.

A Customized Vegan Masala Sauce Recipe

This tikka masala sauce can easily be customized into a Vegan recipe. All you need to do is swap out a few ingredients. Simply:

Use oil rather than unsalted butter at the very beginningOmit the butter at the end. Alternatively, stir in a few tablespoons of coconut cream.Use agave as the sweetener since honey is not vegan.

How To Use This Tikka Sauce

This is a versatile base sauce recipe that can build a meal based on whatever you’re craving. Below are some of my favorite ways to use tikka masala sauce. Simply add BITE-SIZE pieces of any ONE of the following to your sauce as follows:

How To Store

Homemade tikka masala sauce is best stored in a jar or airtight container in the fridge for 4-5 days. If you are not planning on using the sauce within that timeframe, simply freeze the entire recipe or in individual portions.

Freezer Tikka Masala Sauce

There are two options - in one large airtight container or individual portions. For both, make sure to cool completely before storing.

One Container: Place in a tight-sealing container, label, date and freeze for up to 2 months.Individual Portions: Portion into round silicone molds and place in your freezer until set, about 1 hour. Transfer to a freezer-safe plastic storage bag, seal tight, label, date and freeze for up to 2 months.

Thaw and Use

When ready to use, thaw the one container of sauce overnight in the refrigerator and use it as directed above.For the individual portions, 1 cube = ¼ cup sauce, so simply pop one (or two) out of the freezer any time the craving strikes and melt in a skillet with your cooked protein or vegetable of choice until warmed through.

Recipe Tips:

There is no need to worry about slicing and chopping the aromatics to the right size since the tikka masala will be pureed at the very end. If you do not own an immersion blender, cool the sauce completely and transfer to a blender to puree until smooth.If you are making this sauce recipe when tomatoes are in season, use 4-5 ripe Roma tomatoes for their super fresh flavor.Can’t find dried fenugreek leaves? Skip it. Many sources suggest maple syrup or mustard as a substitute for fenugreek leaves, but it isn’t a perfect match in this recipe. Don’t worry, you’ll still have a rock-solid sauce to enjoy. This recipe has been tested in a 6 QT Instant Pot. If making this in an 8 QT size, increase water quantity to meet the requirement.When using the Stovetop method, stir a few times during simmering to prevent the sauce from sticking to the bottom. If it looks dry, add a little water and continue cooking.